Skills-Based Talent Architecture and the Decline of Credential-Based Hiring
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.71086/IAJOBHRM/V11I1/IAJOBHRM1104Keywords:
Skills-Based Hiring, Talent Architecture, Credentialism, Degree Inflation, Talent Management, Personnel Selection, HR Analytics.Abstract
Hiring based on credentials, where the degrees and diplomas as well as institutional affiliation are viewed as measures of competence, is becoming increasingly less relevant as the workplace is organized around constantly changing tasks. The current study addresses how a skills-based talent architecture is introduced in place of credential filtering as an organizing principle of recruitment, staffing, and development processes. An integrative literature review approach was used to screen, code, and synthesize twenty studies published between 2015 and 2022 in terms of theme, methodology, and architecture. The findings indicate that there are five inter-related layers in the architecture: skills ontology and taxonomy; skills evidence and assessment; talent matching and internal mobility; development and reskilling; and governance, fairness and analytics. It is found that there is more literature devoted to the layers of assessment and governance rather than skills taxonomy and internal mobility. From a rubric-based comparison, the skills architecture beats the credential one in the following areas: scope of the talent pool, adaptability to changes in the task, internal mobility, and accuracy of predictions. However, the skills-based architecture lags behind in terms of implementation readiness and efficiency in screening. It can be noted that the shift from credentialism to non-credentialism is not a matter of changing policies but the matter of architecture that relies on the reliability of skills data, accountability of algorithms, and the competence of line managers.
