Ethical Implications of Genetic and Biometric Data Use in Employment Decisions
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.71086/IAJOBHRM/V13I3/IAJOBHRM1311Keywords:
Genetic Data, Biometric Data, Employment Decisions, Workplace Privacy, Ethical Implications, Employment Discrimination, Data Protection.Abstract
Decisions related to employment have always involved inferring future performance from available evidence, but the type of information being used for inference is evolving. Genetic testing is supposed to provide information on susceptibility to disease as well as interaction between genes and environment; biometrics translates fingerprints, face structure, voice patterns, and body movement into claims of identity. Such information differs in fundamental ways from the traditional personnel information available to the employer: it is immutable, intimately connected to identity, often shared with family members without their consent, and predictive in nature rather than merely descriptive. The objective of this paper is to analyze the ethical dimensions of using such data in hiring, promotion, accommodation, and firing decisions. The legal regime dealing with genetic and biometric data is described in this paper, and it is shown to be fractured, inadequate, and based on consent impossible to obtain within an employment relationship. It goes on to formulate an ethics analysis from the perspective of autonomy, privacy, dignity, distributive justice, and proportionality, stating that the two principles which can stand up to analysis – the protection of the health of workers and the protection of third parties from harm – limit the legitimate scope of genetic/biometric screening much more than the practice currently allows. To facilitate empirical studies in the field, the article formulates a research design and a full-fledged SPSS analysis protocol, detailing the variables to be used, the hypotheses to be tested, the statistical tests to be performed, and the output format; synthesizing the quantitative results already published.
