Constructive Dismissal and the Legal Boundaries of Flexible Work Arrangements
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.71086/IAJOBHRM/V13I3/IAJOBHRM1312Keywords:
Constructive Dismissal, Flexible Work, Employment Law, Workplace Rights, Employment Contract, Labour Relations, Legal Compliance.Abstract
Flexibility at work has shifted from the periphery of the employment relationship to its core, and employers are trying to regain control over a form of flexibility that workers consider finalised. The legal implication of such a move is one that is often overlooked: where an employer rescinds or significantly limits a flexibility option without agreement from the worker, the subsequent resignation of the worker could be legally redefined as dismissal. In this paper, the concept of constructive dismissal is explored as the process through which the legal limits of flexibility at work are set, in the sense that it is precisely through the operation of the doctrine that workers' resignations become legally constituted dismissals. The argument unfolds via the wide definition and high evidentiary requirements of the doctrine, variation, breach and repudiation mechanisms, the uncertain legal character of flexible work as a classification and unclear dividing line between the right to impose return-to-office policies and duty of providing reasonable accommodation, and availability and disconnection as the aspect of working time regulation. Litigation risks are assessed for the main types of organizational action in this context, and a governance approach based on the clear contract, consultation, consistency, and justification is suggested. The key thesis is that the limits of acceptable management of flexibility lie not in the generosity of employer’s policy but in the contract, and that employers who see hybrid and remote working as policy options rather than contract rights are building up their dismissal liability.
